You are exactly right, that was the very same problems I was having. I could get in using init 3 but that was the only way. I also installed fedora using text only. I was dissapointed I tell you none the least because it came down to not being able to see what was going on when I knew that everything was setup properly. I unfortunately never tried another videio card because I didn't have one.
About a year ago I bought this LCD and and about a month ago it stopped working when I moved my mouse so I thought that I blew the lamp or something so taking a shot in the dark I plugged it in and it worked just perfect. I am very grateful for that otherwise I was planning on maybe trying another distro. I spent literally two days reading and talking in IRC to try and figure out what would make a monitor just black out like that. I looked in the XF86Config file and everything to everyone's believe said it looked fine and they too were just as baffled.
I have to admit it was a 10 year old MAG innovision monitor but I hate to even utter the words, (worked fine for Windoze). I made the decision to go to Linux because I had nothing that was tying me to Windoze and I must say honestly I am very much happen with my decision despite a few minor bugs here and there but I know in time they will be worked out.
I wish everyone the best of luck with anyone that should encounter the same problem and maybe there will be another fix to this problem.
.: I also tried to change the monitor type in XF86Config to a generic monitor setting at the lowest res and that too did no justice!!
